Monday, August 31, 2009

Non-Fiction Book

I have read three possible choices for a non-fiction book this summer. They are all books about surgeons and/or persons in the medical field. I haven't chosen one specific one yet, but when the time comes to write the book report, i'm sure any of the three will do justice.

The Prevailing Opinion of a Sexual Character Discussed

When I first started reading this essay, I was very interested in the topic and the passion that Wollstonecraft wrote with. Wollstonecraft transferred her emotions into the paper, and as a reader, I could feel them come off the page. There were some confusing parts; I didn't understand who some people were in the essay, and some of the words were just too Old English for me.

The flow was nice from the beginning, going from a women to a man to a child. The examples Wollstonecraft criticized were also nicely done, organized well, and explained thoroughly. However I think that how Wollstonecraft described a woman was not well done. She made me think that the women in that time were stupid and incompetent.

Wollstonecraft also added extra bits about soldiers and love that were not needed and actually distracted from her point and the focus of the essay. Also, about half way through the paper, Wollstonecraft got a little redundant. She stated that women were flimsy characters and needed to be treated equally so that they could get a chance to be something else. The last couple pages were basically that just reworded into more confusing words. I mean come on, we got the point already!

Wollstonecraft didn't have the opposing side in her paper either. She just stated her beliefs like they were the only choice and that she was 100% correct. Well i'm sure people in that time didn't exactly agree with her, so why didn't she explain their ideas, and then write why she thought they were wrong?

Some pages in the essay just got so boring I couldn't read it, and had to skim. Also the organization was off in some parts, and the flow became choppy and skewed towards the end.

By the end of the essay, I was glad to just have finished it without falling asleep.

Saturday, August 1, 2009

Is Google Making Us Stupid?

Nicholas Carr does a nice job in the introduction. After reading the first paragraph, I wanted to continue, wondering why computers and memory circuits were the first things mentioned. In the second paragraph, he connects with the reader. Anyone's mind could be changing, and the way Carr describes it makes the reader feel like they aren't the only ones too. The style Carr writes in is more appealing to me than any of the other essays. His writing just seems to connect with me more, maybe because it's about the Internet and I have the same feeling on the topic.

I thought that the paragraph on reading and how we have to teach ourselves was very interesting. I had no clue that the media and other technologies shape the neural circuits in our brain. I think that section pulls the whole essay together, because there is actual scientific fact that Internet and media change our brain. I was very interested in the whole page talking about the brain because I want to major in neuroscience. The facts were very interesting and having direct quotes from authority figures in neuroscience reassured me that the facts were true.

One thing I thought Carr could do better was explain the Internet a little bit more. For some people who have no clue how it works or the details, an explanation would be very informative.

It was surprising to see the story about Frederick Winslow Taylor in the essay. I learned about Taylor in AP US--"Taylorism"--and didn't know the background story on why he was tracking the efficiency of workers. This is another part I really enjoyed, the history involved in Carr's topic. Carr used his transitions very well, they flow smoothly and I didn't experience any choppiness like other essays. The conclusion match the introduction, and the essay in a whole left me wondering what Google and the Internet will turn out to be.

It was ironic that Carr said he had trouble reading more than a three page blog/essay when he himself wrote an almost 7 page paper for others to read.